Osteoporosis, osteopenia and fracture risk: Widening the therapeutic horizons
Dennis A Davey
The majority of women with fragility fractures have osteopenia rather than osteoporosis. In post hoc analyses of trials of alendronate and strontium ranelate, women with osteopenia had significant reductions in the incidence of fragility fractures and specific therapies may be mandated in women with osteopenia, as well as those with osteoporosis. Increasing numbers of fractures of the spine and hip occur in very elderly women and men over the age of 80, but in this age group it is often considered too late in life to start long-term specific therapies. In clinical trials of very elderly women, risendronate significantly reduced vertebral fractures and strontium ranelate significantly reduced vertebral, non-vertebral and symptomatic clinical fractures within 1 year of starting treatment. The indications for specific therapies for osteopenia and osteoporosis, as well as other measures for the prevention and treatment of fragility fractures, urgently need to be increased and widened.
S Afr Med J 2012;102(5):285-288.
Professor Davey trained at St Mary’s Hospital and the Postgraduate Medical School in London and was Head of the Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology of the University of Cape Town from 1965 to1990. He was a specialist in the Department from 1991 to 2012 and was associated with the Mature Women’s Clinic with a special interest in problems of the menopause, including the diagnosis and treatment of osteoporosis.
Corresponding author: D A Davey (email@example.com)
Osteoporosis is defined as a progressive systemic skeletal disease characterised by low bone mass and micro-architectural deterioration of bone tissue with a consequent increase in bone fragility and susceptibility to fracture.
There is still uncertainty about the diagnosis and management of osteoporosis and osteopenia (low bone mass) and the medical management of low trauma (fragility) fractures, particularly in the very elderly. Recommendations from authorities including the National Osteoporosis Foundation of South Africa (NOFSA), National Osteoporosis Foundation of the USA (NOF) and National Osteoporosis Guideline Group of the UK (NOGG) are often not implemented.1 Responsibility for management moreover is divided between many different specialties.
Osteoporosis and osteopenia (low bone mass) are now widely diagnosed by measuring bone mineral density (BMD) using dual energy X-ray absorptiometry (DEXA) of the upper femur and lumbar spine. The criteria for the diagnosis of osteoporosis and osteopenia, however, vary between the different authorities with regard to the site at which BMD is measured and the number of bone sites included.
The World Health Organization (WHO) designates ‘osteoporosis’ as a BMD 2.5 standard deviations (SD) or more below the young adult mean value for women (a T-score equal to or less than -2.5 SD in postmenopausal women). A BMD measurement of between -1 SD and -2.5 SD is designated as ‘osteopenia’ or ‘low bone mass’.4 The WHO recommends that osteoporosis and osteopenia be diagnosed solely on the BMD measurement of the femoral neck, using the data of the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES) for Caucasian women aged 20 - 29 years as the normal reference range. The BMD of the femoral neck alone is recommended for diagnosing osteoporosis and osteopenia because of its higher predictive value for future fractures. Prediction of fracture risk is claimed not to be improved by using multiple sites for the measurement of BMD. The spine is not regarded as suitable, particularly in the elderly, because of the high prevalence of osteo-arthritis and spinal abnormalities that may affect BMD measurements.
The International Society for Clinical Densitometry (ISCD) recommends that osteoporosis be diagnosed in postmenopausal women and men aged 50 and older if the lowest level of the T-score of the femoral neck or the total upper femur or the lumbar spine is -2.5 or less, and that osteopenia be diagnosed if the lowest level of the T-score is -1.0 or less but above -2.5. 5 Measurement of the lumbar spine is based on the mean of L1 - L4 vertebrae, excluding any vertebra that is more than 1 SD from an adjacent vertebra but including a minimum of two vertebrae.
NOFSA recommends that osteoporosis and osteopenia be diagnosed by the International. Society for Clinical Densitometry (ISCD) criteria or the presence of a fragility fracture (with or without BMD measurement) in postmenopausal women and men over 50 years of age:1
• T-score <-2.5 of the femoral neck or total femur or lumbar spine inserted)
• T-score -1.0 to -2.5 (osteopenia) with two or more clinical risk factors including age 75 years or older
• A prior osteoporotic fracture of hip, humerus, pelvis, rib or wrist, irrespective of BMD.
The female reference data for women are applied to the T-score in men as recommended by the WHO. NOFSA also recommends that all patients qualifying for a BMD measurement should have an X-ray of the spine or a DEXA-based vertebral fracture assessment, using the Genant semi-quantitative system (grade 1 - 3).6 A reduction in vertebral height of at least 20% or 4 mm is required to diagnose a vertebral fracture.
BMD measurements can be used for diagnosis of osteoporosis and osteopenia in individuals or for population screening to determine those at increased fracture risk. NOGG recommends that BMD measurements should only be used for case finding, as BMD measurements have a high specificity but low sensitivity for future fractures.3 NOFSA recommends BMD testing of all women 65 years and older, all men 70 years or older, and all women and men with clinical risk factors for osteoporosis and osteopenia, including all those who have had a fracture after age 40 or with known causes of secondary osteoporosis.1
Assessment of fracture risk
BMD measurements are a continuum, and the risk of fracture approximately doubles with each decrease in SD below the young adult mean. BMD, however, accounts for less than 50% of bone strength, and many factors related to BMD and independent of BMD affect both bone strength and fracture risk
The WHO combined these factors in a fracture risk assessment, the FRAX score (with or without BMD measurement of the femoral neck), to give a 10-year probability of the risk of future hip fracture or of a major osteoporotic fracture (clinical fracture of the spine, hip, forearm or humerus) in women and men 50 years of age or older (Table 1).7 A FRAX tool for assessing fracture risk probability is freely available online (www.shef.ac.uk/FRAX). The FRAX score is primarily recommended for identifying individual women or men for specific treatment of osteoporosis.
The FRAX score depends on the prevalence of fractures and the mortality in any group or country. It has been validated in the UK and Sweden and evaluated in other countries with differing fracture and mortality rates, including the USA. Modified FRAX scores and tables of fracture probability have been published for these countries.8 , 9 In the USA FRAX models for Asians, blacks and Hispanics have also been developed because their hip and osteoporotic fracture rates are lower than those in USA whites. No data are available for the fracture rates for different ethnic groups in South Africa.
The FRAX fracture risk assessment tool has limitations, and in particular does not include the number and recentness of previous fractures, the risk of falls and the dose and duration of glucocorticoids. The risk of a further fracture is highest in the first few years after a fracture and the risk of a vertebral fracture is increased 5-fold in the first year after a vertebral fracture. FRAX may underestimate fracture risk in individuals with recent fracture, those with recent falls, and those receiving high doses of glucocorticoids. Fracture risk scores that include a history of falls have been introduced including the Qfracture score in the UK and the Garvan Fracture Risk Calculator (GFRC) in the USA.10 , 11 The GFRC is a web-based tool that includes recent falls (1, 2 and >2 falls) and number of previous fractures (1, 2 and >2), but does not include some risk factors included in FRAX. FRAX underestimates fracture risk in patients with 2 or more previous fractures or one or more recent falls, but GFRC underestimates fracture risk in women with a parental history of hip fracture and in those with secondary osteoporosis. The difficulties and objections raised regarding the FRAX tool are discussed in ‘Frequently Asked Questions’ on its website. NOFSA proposed an integrated approach to screening and management based on FRAX but recognising its limitations, and has an algorithm for the selection of women and men aged 50 years or older for BMD testing based on clinical risk factors (including advanced age) and for treatment (Fig. 1).1
The problem of osteopenia
The ‘Geoffrey Rose Prevention Paradox’ applies to many chronic diseases, including osteopenia: ‘a large number of people at small risk give rise to more cases than the small number who are at high risk’. In most countries less than half of women and men who sustain a fragility fracture have osteoporosis as diagnosed by DEXA measurements of BMD. The majority have osteopenia (low bone mass). In the NORA (Nordic Research on Ageing) study in the USA using peripheral BMD measurement of 149 562 postmenopausal women aged 50 - 104 years (mean 64.5 years), only 6.4% of women had a BMD of <-2.5 SD (associated with 18% of all fractures and 26% of hip fractures), but 45.3 % of women had a BMD of <1.0 SD (associated with 70% of all fractures and 77% of hip fractures).12 In the Rotterdam study of 4 878 women who had DEXA measurements of the femoral neck and were followed up for a mean 6.8 years, the rate of self-reported non-vertebral fractures was 44% with osteoporosis, 43.3% with osteopenia and 12.6% with normal BMD.13 In an Australian community study of 616 women who had DEXA measurements of the total femur, 124 women had one or more fractures. Of the women with fractures, only 26.9% had osteoporosis, 56.5% had osteopenia and 16.6% had a normal BMD.14 Most women and men who suffer from a fragility fracture do not have osteoporosis as defined by the WHO. Therefore, assessment of fracture risk and diagnosis and treatment should not be limited to those with osteoporosis but should include all patients with osteopenia and all patients with clinical risk factors for fracture.
A recent publication from the Study of Osteoporotic Fractures Research Group in the USA has related the estimated time interval for 10% of women with different degrees of osteopenia to make the transition from osteopenia to osteoporosis. Normal BMD was defined as a T-score at the femoral neck and total hip of -1.00 or higher and osteopenia as a T-score of -1.01 to -2.49. Mild, moderate and advanced osteopenia were defined as T-scores of -1.10 to -1.49, -1.50 to -1.99 and -2.0 to -2.49, respectively. The intervals between baseline testing and development of osteoporosis in 4 957 women aged 67 years and older (adjusted for BMI, current oestrogen use and smoking, current or past use of oral glucocorticoids and rheumatoid arthritis) in years with 95% confidence limits were: normal BMD 16.8 (11.5 - 24.6), mild osteopenia 17.3 (13.9 - 21.5), moderate osteopenia 4.7 (4.2 - 5.2), advanced osteopenia 1.1 (1.0 - 1.3). It is clear that the degree of osteopenia is a major factor in predicting the development of osteoporosis and of consequent fracture risk and the degree of osteopenia should be taken into account in arriving at all treatment decisions 15
Criteria for diagnosis are not the same as those for treating osteoporosis and osteopenia. Treatment must be based on assessing future fracture risk and on the medical state of each individual. Authorities agree that decisions about treatment must be individualised and based on good clinical judgement, taking into account patient preferences, co-morbidities, previous drug use and risk factors not captured in FRAX, and possible under- or overestimation of fracture risk by FRAX. Guidelines for treating osteoporosis/osteopenia include the recent excellent NOFSA Guideline for the Diagnosis and Management of Osteoporosis.1
Management of osteopenia
Women and men with osteopenia are generally considered to be at low risk of fracture. They are often managed with advice about calcium and vitamin D supplementation and lifestyle changes, but are not given any specific therapy. Most clinical trials of specific therapies for osteoporosis and osteopenia have focused on patients with osteoporosis and/or the presence of hip or vertebral fracture. Few randomised controlled trials have been performed on patients with osteopenia, but some have included osteopenic patients allowing post hoc analyses. In the Fracture Intervention Trial (FIT) 1 and FIT 2 trials of patients with osteopenia of the femoral neck with and without vertebral fractures, alendronate decreased the risk of radiological fractures (relative risk (RR) 0.48, 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.41 - 0.81) and of clinical vertebral fractures (RR 0.41, 95% CI 0.19 - 0.76).16 In the Spinal Osteoporosis Therapeutic Intervention SOTI) and TReatment Of Peripheral OSteoporosis (TROPOS) trials in women with osteopenia of the lumbar spine, strontium ranelate reduced the risk of vertebral fracture in women with no prevalent fractures (RR 0.41, 95% CI 0.17 - 0.99) and in women with prevalent fractures (RR 0.62, 95% CI 0.44 - 0.88).17 In women with osteopenia at both the lumbar spine and femoral neck, treatment with strontium ranelate reduced the risk of fracture (RR 0.48, 95% CI 0.24 - 0.96). Specific drug treatment appears to be effective and is justified to reduce the risk of further fractures in patients with osteopenia, particularly those with prevalent fractures.
Management of osteoporosis and osteopenia in the very elderly
Very elderly women and men
(aged 80 years and over) are the fastest-growing segment of the
population. About 25 - 30% of the population burden of all fragility
fractures is in women and men over 80, who are at high risk for
fracture, particularly non-vertebral fracture, because of their high
prevalence of osteoporosis and osteopenia and high incidence of falls.
After a hip fracture approximately 20% of patients do not survive more
than a year and 50% do not regain their previous level of independence.
Vertebral fractures are associated with back pain, height loss,
kyphosis and functional disability. The prevalence of vertebral
deformities increases from 5 - 10% in women in the 50s to 45 - 55% of
those in the 80s. Only a proportion of older women and men with
osteoporosis or osteopenia receive specific treatment. Some clinicians
may consider that patients over 80 years are too old, or that it is too
late to significantly alter the course of the disease. Based on pooled
data of 1 392 women aged 80 or over from the HIP, VERT-MN and VERT-NA
trials, risendronate resulted in a 44% reduction in vertebral fractures
but not in non-vertebral fractures.18
In 1 488 women between 80 and 100 years of age from the SOTI and TROPOS
trials and followed up for 3 years, strontium ranelate reduced the risk
of vertebral, non-vertebral and clinical symptomatic fractures within
the first year by 59% (p=0.002), 41% (p=0.027) and 37% (p=0.012), respectively.19 At the end of 3 years vertebral, non-vertebral and symptomatic clinical fractures were reduced by 32% (p=0.013), 31% (p=0.011) and 22% (p=0.040),
respectively. Strontium ranelate was reported to be well tolerated and
as safe as in younger patients. Women and men are therefore never too
old for treatment, and it is never too late to treat those with
osteoporosis or osteopenia, particularly when they have a fragility
Responsibility for diagnosis and management
Patients with osteoporosis and osteopenia are treated by general practitioners and specialists from various disciplines including orthopaedics, rheumatology, gynaecology, geriatrics and endocrinology. Knowledge and understanding of the diagnosis and treatment of osteoporosis and of fragility fractures is increasing and new treatment options are being developed. Few specialties require training in osteoporosis and metabolic bone diseases for higher professional qualification. A good case can be made for the establishment of local groups, including generalists and specialists who are especially interested in osteoporosis, to agree on referral practices and treatment based on local resources. In large hospitals an ‘osteoporosis clinic’ including different disciplines may facilitate diagnosis and management. There is little doubt that the care of women and men with osteoporosis or osteopenia and those with fragility fractures, particularly the very elderly, can be enormously improved.
1. Hough S, Ascott-Evans B, Brown S, for the National Osteoporosis Foundation of South Africa (NOFSA). NOFSA Guideline for the Diagnosis and Management of Osteoporosis. Journal of Endocrinology, Metabolism and Diabetes of South Africa 2010:15(3, suppl 1):107-108. http://www.osteoporosis.org.za (accessed 7 November 2011).
2. National Osteoporosis Foundation. Clinician’s Guide to Prevention and Treatment of Osteoporosis. Washington, DC: National Osteoporosis Foundation, 2010. http://www.nof.org (7 November 2011).
3. National Osteoporosis Guideline Group (NOGG). Osteoporosis Clinical Guideline for Prevention and Treatment, Executive Summary (updated 2010). University of Sheffield Press. http://www.shef.ac.uk/NOGG/(accessed 7 November 2011).
4. World Health Organization. Assessment of fracture risk and application to screening for postmenopausal osteoporosis. World Health Organ Tech Rep Ser 1994;843.
5. International Society for Clinical Densitometry 2007. Official positions and pediatric official positions of the International Society for Clinical Densitometry. J Clin Den 2008;11(1):75-91. http://www.iscd.org/visitors/pdfs/SCD2007OfficialPositions-combined-AdultandPediatric.pdf (accessed 7 November 2011).
6. Genant KH, Wu C, Van Kuijk C, et al. Vertebral fracture assessment using a semi-quantitative approach. J Bone Miner Res 1993;8:1137-1148.
7. Kanis JA, Oden A, Johansson H, et al. FRAX and its application in clinical practice. Bone 2009;44:734-743.
8. Tosteson AN, Melton LJ, Dawson-Hughes B, et al. Cost-effective osteoporosis treatment thresholds: The US perspective from the National Osteoporosis Foundation Guide Committee. Osteoporos Int 2008;19(4):437-447.
9. Dawson-Hughes B, Tosteson AN, Melton LJ, et al. Implications of absolute fracture risk assessment for osteoporosis practice guidelines in the US. Osteoporos Int 2008;19(4):449-458.
10. Collins GS, Mallett S, Altman DG. Predicting risk of osteoporotic and hip fracture in the United Kingdom: prospective independent and external validation of QFractures Scores. BMJ 2011;342:d3651.
11. Bolland MJ, Mason BH, Horne AM, et al. Evaluation of the FRAX and Garvan fracture risk calculator in older women. J Bone Miner Res 2011;26(2):420-427
12. Siris ES, Chen YT, Abbott TA, et al. Bone mineral density thresholds for pharmacological intervention to prevent fractures. Arch Intern Med 2004;164(10):1108-1112.
13. Schuit SC, Van der Klift M, de Laet CE, et al. Fracture incidence and association with bone mineral density in elderly men and women: the Rotterdam study. Bone 2004;34(1):195-202.
14. Pasco JA, Seeman E, Henry MJ, Merriman EN, Nicholson GC, Kotowicz MA. The population burden of fractures originates in women with osteopenia not osteoporosis. Osteoporos Int 2006;17(9):1404-1409.
15. Gourlay ML, Fine JP. Preisser JS et al. Bone-density testing interval and transition to osteoporosis in older women. N Engl J Med 2012;366:225-233.
16. Quandt SA, Thompson DE, Schneider DL, Nevitt MC, Black DM. Effect of alendronate on vertebral fracture risk in women with bone mineral density T scores of -1.6 to -2.5 at the femoral neck: the Fracture Intervention Trial. Mayo Clin Proc 2005;80:343-349.
17. Seeman E Devogelaer JP, Lorenc R, et al. Strontium ranelate reduces risk of vertebral fractures in patients with osteopenia. J Bone Miner Res 2008;23:433-438.
18. Mc Clung MR, Geusens P, Miller PD, et al. Efffect of risendronate on the risk of hip fracture in elderly women: Hip Intervention Program study group. N Engl J Med 2001;344(5):333-340.
19. Seeman E, Vellas B, Benhamou C, et al. Strontium ranelate reduces the risk of vertebral and non-vertebral fracture in women eighty years age and older. J Bone Miner Res 2006;21(7):1113-1120.
Table 1. FRAX clinical risk factors7 for the assessment of fracture probability
Male or female
Low body mass
Yes/no, clinical or X-ray hip, spine or wrist
Parental history of hip fracture
Current glucocorticoid treatment
Yes/no, oral, any dose for >3 months
Yes/ no, 3 or more units daily
Secondary causes of osteoporosis*
*Rheumatoid arthritis, type 1 diabetes, hyperthyroidism, hypogonadism, gastro-intestinal disease, chronic liver disease, pulmonary disease, organ transplantation.
Fig. 1. Algorithm for the management of osteoporosis in postmenopausal women and men aged 50 years and older.
Full text views: 12429